Supreme Court of the United States April 15, 1901, 117 (Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Call Publishing Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-04-1901

Mr. Justice Bbewee,

after stating the case, delivered the opinion of the court.

The contention of the telegraph company is substantially, that the services which it rendered to the publishing company were a matter of interstate commerce; that Congress has sole jurisdiction over such matters, and can alone prescribe rules and regulations therefor; that it had not at the time these services were rendered prescribed any'regulations concerning them; that there is no national common law, and that whatever may be the statute or common law of Nebraska is wholly immaterial; and that, therefore, there being no controlling statute or common law, the state court erred in holding t the telegraph company liable for any discrimination in its charges between the plaintiff and the Journal company. In the brief of counsel it is said: “ The contention was consistently and continuously made upon the trial by the telegraph company that, as to the state law, it could not apply for the reasons already given, and "that, in the absence of a statute by Congress declaring a rule as to interstate traffic by the telegraph company, such as was appealed to by the publishing company, there was no law upon the subject.” The logical result of this contention is that persons dealing with

*95

common carriers engaged in interstate commerce and in respect to such commerce are absolutely at the mercy of the carriers. It is true counsel do not insist that the telegraph company or any other company engaged in interstate commerce may charge or-contract for unreasonable rates, but they do not say that they may not, and if there be neither statute nor

common

law controlling the action of interstate carriers, there is nothing to •limit their obligation in respect to the matter of reasonableness.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.