Court of Appeals of Texas December 3, 1902 (Turner v. Cochran)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-12-1902

*550

GILL, Associate Justice.

The appellees, Mary A. Cochran, joined pro forma by her husband, originally brought two suits against W. B. Turner for the recovery of 1476 acres of land alleged to be situated in Montgomery County, Texas, and described as one-third of a league originally granted to Jas. W. Henderson, assignee of S. J. Rickhow. These suits were filed one in Montgomery County and one in Harris County. The form of the actions was trespass to try title. By agreement of counsel the Montgomery County suit was transferred to Harris County and there consolidated with the Harris County suit. The latter was filed February 28, 1900, and the former March 3, 1900. John Hammon intervened in the suit, claiming title, and H. Masterson was also made a party. He answered setting up some claim to the land, but offered no proof upon the trial. Appellees prevailed upon the first trial, and upon appeal the judgment was affirmed by this court. 63 S. W. Rep., 151.

Pending motion for rehearing the controlling question was certified and upon the answers of the Supreme Court (61 Southwestern Reporter, 923) the judgment was reversed and.the cause remanded. On a second trial the appellees again prevailed, and this is a second appeal.

The pleadings present the issues herein discussed and need not be set out either in substance or at length. The facts established on the last trial are so entirely different from the first that a full restatement of the substance of the evidence is necessary. The history of the title to the land involved in this suit is as follows:

On the 29th day of September, 1851, the 1476 acres of land in controversy was patented to James W. Henderson, assignee of Samuel J. Rickhow, and was described in the patent as situated in Montgomery County, Texas. On March 23, 1853, J. W. Henderson sold and conveyed the land to James A. Thompson. On the 12th day of August, 1856, Thompson made and delivered a deed absolute in form with covenants of warranty naming Wm. R.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.