Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York July 1, 1902 (Westphal v. City of New York)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-07-1902
Woodward, J.:
. These actions, involving the same general questions, were tried together, resulting in judgments in favor of the plaintiffs, at Special Term. The plaintiffs, who asked for the equitable interposition of the court to prevent a continuing trespass upon the part of the defendant, under the rule established in the cases of Smith v. City of Brooklyn (160 N. Y. 357) and Forbell v. City of New York (164 id. 522), are not satisfiéd with the amount of the recovery, and *254appeal from the judgments entered in their favor. The evidence received in this case was, tó a considerable extent, such as was condemned in the- case of Reisert v. City of New York (69 App. Div. 302), but there appears to have been no objection to its admission, and we are to determine whether the court below has determined the questions upon the evidence before it in accord with the established principles of equity jurisprudence.
The plaintiff, Westphal, is the owner of five and one-half acres of market garden land located in Kings county, extending from the Old Mill road to Spring creek, about 60Ó feet southwest of the Spring Creek pumping'station of defendant’s water works, and the learned court at Special Term has found that “ the operation by' the City of Brooklyn from 1894 to January 1st, 1898,' and by the defendant since that date, of the driven wells and pumping stations at Spring Creek station of defendant’s water works, formerly owned by the City of Brooklyn and now owned by the defendant, lowered and lowers the water table or level under plaintiff’s land from where it formerly was to a depth varying from said former level to about six feet below it, according to whether said pumps are worked or not,” and that “by reason of the operation of said pumping stations, and the lowering of said water table, the plaintiff has been damaged, up to the time of this trial, in the sum of $350, and the permanent damage to the plaintiff’s said land thereby is $300.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit