Supreme Court of Pennsylvania May 19, 1902, Appeal, No. 68 (Bennett Water Co. v. Millvale Borough)
Also known as
United States · · · 19-05-1902
Opinion by
Mr. Justice Dean,
The history of this litigation is not a short one. It will be found reported in Howard’s Appeal, 162 Pa. 374, and in the appeal of the borough in which opinion was handed down at Pittsburg at October term, 1901, and is reported in 200 Pa. 613.
On a motion for reargument, after the last decision, we decided to hear a reargument on the assignment of error to the charge of the court on the measure of damages and to the rejection of testimony offered by appellant bearing on that question. Appellant’s counsel who prepared this paper-book, seems to have thought, we desired to hear, as well, a criticism of the former rulings of this court on the whole case. This is a mistake; he has wasted much time and taken much trouble on a subject which has no bearing whatever on the question directed to be reargued.
At the former argument, but little stress was put on the question now for consideration, and that we might get further light on the subject, and if any mistake had been made, correct it, was our purpose in ordering the reargument.
It is complained, that the court in its charge admitted in evidence the gross amount of water rents received by the borough from its own plant from the date of its construction up to December 22, 1899, the date of plaintiff’s suit, and then, practically directed the jury to take this amount as the measure of damages. Picking out certain phrases in the charge and *618adopting them as the substance of the charge, on this subject, the argument of appellant might be sustained; but such interpretation wholly disregards the plain meaning of the entire charge, as well as many facts of which there was no direct testimony, but assumed by both parties and the court at the trial. After stating the gross amount of the receipts from the consumers who took water from the borough plant, the court says the plaintiff is entitled, “ to recover such amount as will make it whole. . . . The receipts of the borough were 133,467.91.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit