Supreme Court of Alabama November 15, 1902 (Berry v. Tennessee & Coosa Railroad)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-11-1902

TYSON, J.

The original bill Avas filed by the Tennessee & Coosa Railroad Company against Fannie M. Berry, alleging that each oAvned an undivided one-half *621interest in certain lands described; tbat said lands could not be equitably, divided by metes and bounds, and prayed that the same be sold and proceeds divided. Upon a demurrer being sustained to it, the complainant was allowed to file a substituted bill by way of amendment. This amended bill is filed by tbe same complainant “who sues on behalf of Anna J. Henderson” and is exhibited against Anna J. Henderson a.nd Fannie M. Berry. After setting forth the manner by which the complainant railroad company acquired its title to a half interest in the lands described and sought to be partitioned, it is averred that the railroad company executed a. deed conveying its said one-half undivided interest in said land's to one Carlisle who afterwards died leaving Anna J. Henderson, his sole heir at law; that at the date of the execution of said deed, the respondent Mrs. Berry, having previously ousted the said railroad company from the possession and enjoyment of .its interest in said lands, was in the adverse possession of the same claiming’ to he the owner of that interest under color of title.

The prayer is for a. partition of said lands by metes and- hounds ,otc. and not for a sale.

It is objected by Mrs. Berry that this amendment was improper for three reasons: First, that it is a departure from the original cause of action; second, that it wrought an entii*e change of parties, and third, that the railroad company has parted with its title. These objections were raised in the court below by demurrer and constitute tbe main contention here.

The: purpose of both the original and amended hill was a partition of the lauds — to separate the respective shares, either by having the lands partitioned im kind or to- have the tract sold and its proceeds divided.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.