Indiana Court of Appeals October 9, 1902, No. 4,082 (Cox v. Cohn)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-10-1902
Wiley, C. J.
Appellees, as executors of the last will and testament of Nicholas Schultz, deceased, filed their petition in the court below to sell certain real estate in pursuance to a provision of the will. Appellant Cox, who was *560an occupant of the land, and Angeline Ocher a legatee under the will, were made parties defendant. The petition alleged that Oox was an occupant of the real estate and claimed to have some interest therein, but that said claim was fictitious and unfounded. Oox answered in two paragraphs: (1) A general denial; and (2) averring that he was in possession of the real estate under a lease from the decedent, and that said lease did not terminate until October 1, 1901. Angeline Ocher answered by a general denial. Upon the trial of the cause the court made a general finding in favor of the executors, and directed the sale of the land. The evidence shows that the decedent died August 20, 1900, and that subsequent to his death appellant sowed some twenty acres of wheat on the real estate in controversy. The evidence also shows that appellant had been a tenant of the deceased, and as such had been in possession of the real estate for more than a year prior to the testator’s death. The term of his tenancy expired in October, 1900, unless it was extended by a contract between him and the testator some time prior to his death. As to whether there was such a contract, is the controlling question in the case.
The only error assigned is the overruling of the motion for a new trial. Appellant’s motion for a new trial is based upon four grounds: (1) and (2) That the decision is not sustained by sufficient evidence, and is contrary to law; (3) misconduct of the attorney for appellees in his closing argument; and (d) alleged error of the court in refusing to permit the appellant to testify as to certain facts.
As to the right of the executors to sell the real estate, in pursuance to the directions of the will, there is no contention.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit