Wisconsin Supreme Court October 21, 1902 (Milwaukee Rice Machinery Co. v. Hamacek)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-10-1902

Dodge, J.

1. Several assignments of error are predicated upon admission of evidence over plaintiffs objection. First among these is the inquiry: “Did you buy that engine, relying upon your own judgment as to its condition?” which was answered in the negative. Another exception is predicated upon an analogous question: “In making this purchase, did you rely upon the representations made in the letter of May 9th, and was that part of the transaction, — was that part of the bargain ?” No error was committed in overruling these objections. The questions at issue were whether plaintiff made a warranty, and, secondly, whether defendant bought in reliance thereon. The latter was vigorously controverted. The defendant and the plaintiff’s salesman, Schult, gave contradictory narratives of the transaction between them at which the purchase was made; the salesman asserting that the defendant made full examination of the engine, and the defendant, on the other hand, asserting that he was unable to do so-, and desisted on the faith of the warranty that the engine was “as good as new in every point and particular,” and so notified plaintiff’s agent. The question whether or not he purchased in reliance upon that representation, or whether he substituted therefor Iris own examination of the engine and judgment based thereon, was one of fact, as to which he might properly testify, albeit the testimony relating to mental processes would have been easily overcome by conduct and circumstances.

Another exception was reserved upon the overruling of an *427objection to the question, “What is that engine worth now, in its present condition? Answer, $350.” The trial was had some fifteen months after the sale. During that period the engine had been run almost continuously, and, indeed, according to some evidence, violently. It had been in defendant’s possession, and had been by him taken apart, altered, and modified, and various parts changed, according to his idea of its requirements.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.