Tennessee Supreme Court December 15, 1902 (Marshall & Bruce Co. v. City of Nashville)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-12-1902
lead-opinion
Mr. Justice Wilkes
delivered the opinion of the Court.
This is a bill against the mayor and city council of Nashville to recover eighty-three dollars and five cents and interest for stationery furnished and printed for the city. The city concedes that the account is correct as to items and amounts, hut declines to receive the goods and pay the bill therefor on the ground that the stationery does not hear the union label of the Nashville Allied Trades Council, or the label enacted by the International Typographical Union.
It appears that on December 11,1897, the city council of Nashville passed the following ordinance:
Section 1. Be it enacted that all city printing shall bear the union label of the Nashville Allied Trades Council or the label enacted by the International Typographical Union.
“Sec. 2. That this ordinance shall take effect from and after its 'passage* the welfare of the city requiring it.”
It appears further that in February, 1901, the city, being in need of blank books and stationery over the value of $50, solicited competitive bidiT therefor, specifying what was desired, and complainant, being the *498lowest bidder, was awarded the contract to furnish the goods, and, under its bid and contract, manufactured the articles specified, according to specifications, and delivered some of the letter heads embraced in the order in March, 1901.
After the manufacture of all the items specified, and the advance delivery of the letter heads mentioned, the city notified complainant that it would refuse to receive the goods upon the sole and only ground that they did not bear the union label prescribed by the ordinance, and refused to pay for the goods for the same reason, and thereupon relet the work to the Brandon Printing Company at an advance price of thirty-eight and one half per cent. The bill is filed to recover the amount of complainant’s bill, and to have the ordinance in question declared unreasonable, null, and void.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit