U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Western Missouri April 5, 1902, No. 2,395 (Reading Ins. v. Egelhoff)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-04-1902
PHILIPS, District Judge.
This' cause, after oral argument by the respective counsel, has been submitted, on exceptions filed by each party to the findings of the special master. I have read with care the report of the master, and find that he has presented with singular clearness and impartiality a synopsis of the evidence, and has carefully reviewed the conflicting testimony of the witnesses; and I am unable to say that his deductions therefrom are not well warranted. In a matter of conflicting evidence, especially touching the value of a stock of goods like the one in question, before and after a fire, the conclusions thereon reached by the master should not only be entitled to great weight on review by the court, but should be accepted, unless manifestly erroneous. Especially should this rule be adhered to where it is apparent, as in this case, that the master has applied to the evidence careful consideration and an impartial judgment. Taking all the facts into consideration, his estimate of the actual damages to the stock of goods, resulting from the fire, seems well sustained by the proofs; and I am unable to discover any such false deductions from the testimony, taken in its entirety, as should demand a disturbance by the court of the master’s findings.
It is urged by counsel for respondent that the master failed to make a specific finding as to which of the parties was in fault for the failure to proceed with the arbitration.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit