District Court, S.D. New York July 14, 1902 (Chubb v. New York Cent. & H. R. R.)
Also known as
United States · · · 14-07-1902
ADAMS, District Judge.
This is an action brought to recover for the loss incident to 902 pigs of lead getting overboard from a car float belonging to the Brooklyn Wharf Transfer Company on the 17th day of March, 1898. The lead was loaded in two cars, which were on the rear end of the float when she reached the respondent’s float bridge at the foot of West 60th Street, New York City. It is alleged that a train of cars which was being pushed on the float by one of the respondent’s locomotives struck a train of three cars, two being the lead cars, standing on the float, with the effect of starting the train so that one of the cars went completely off the float and the next car went partly off.
The contention of the libellants is that the respondent’s, agents in loading the cars upon the float negligently caused them to run with such force and violence as to push the cars containing the lead off the float.
The respondent denies the allegations of negligence on its part and alleges that the loss was occasioned by the negligence of the agents of the Brooklyn Wharf and Warehouse Company in removing certain chains which held the cars fast to the float and in placing a weak, insufficient and defective cross pin for a block or buffer between the cars and the outer end of the float, so that when the respondent’s cars were being carefully and properly pushed upon the float, the cars containing the lead started with the result above mentioned. The respondent’s, answer does not admit its train touched the train on the float and its testimony tends to negative any contact.
I think it is probable that a correct determination of the question involved can be reached in ascertaining whether or not there was a contact, because such ascertainment will necessarily tend to credit or discredit the witnesses who have testified adversely to each other in *903that connection and who were the important witnesses for the respective sides.
The float was double ended, with three tracks.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit