Court of Appeals for the Eighth Circuit September 4, 1902, No. 1,603 (Teller v. United States)
Also known as
United States · · · 04-09-1902
lead-opinion
LOCHREN, District Judge,
after stating the case as above, delivered the opinion of the court.
The release of the ties to the defendant by the government by its authorized agent, Abbott, in writing, August 3, 1898, and the defendant’s written agreement of the same date that he would pay for such of the ties as the government was entitled to be paid for, when the number of such ties and the amounts to be paid for them should be ascertained as therein provided for, constituted, together, a valid contract, and then transferred to and vested in the defendant all the title and property right which the government then had in the ties. U. S. v. Teller, 45 C. C. A. 416, 106 Fed. 447. While this contract on the part of the defendant was wholly executory, and to be performed in the then future, on the part of the government, it was wholly executed and performed on the delivery of the written release, so far as vesting in the defendant the government’s title to the ties was concerned. About that matter the government did not stipulate that it would do or refrain from doing anything further. There was not, therefore, and could not be, any breach of the contract in respect to this matter, as to which the contract had been fully and irrevocably performed. The subsequent action of replevin may have been wrongful and baseless, but it was no breach of the contract, and was in fact defeated by that contract, and the property rights which it had vested in the defendant. As the defendant in that action, because of his title derived through that contract, recovered judgment against the government for the value of the ties replevied, there was no failure of consideration, to excuse nonperformance of the contract on his part.
Some of the rulings respecting which error is assigned may be disposed of very briefly.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit