Court of Appeals for the Ninth Circuit October 6, 1902, No. 794 (Nevada Nat. Bank v. Dodge)

Also known as

United States · · · 06-10-1902

DE HAVEN, District Judge.

The appellant is a national banking •association, with its principal place of business at San Francisco, in the state of California, and the bill of complaint in this case was filed by it to enjoin the assessment of its shares of stock to the individual owners thereof; and, the assessment having been made, supplemental bills were filed by it to restrain the collection of the taxes levied upon the assessed valué of such shares. The case' was submitted to the circuit court for decision upon the pleadings and upon an agreed statement of facts, and thereupon a decree was entered by that court dismissing the bill and supplemental bills. The assessment in question was made under an act- of the legislature of the state •of California, approved March 14, 1899 (St. 1899, p. 96), amending sections 3608 and 3609 of the Political Code of the state of California, and adding thereto a new section, numbered 36x0. The sections referred to are as follows:

“3608. Shares of stock in corporations possess no intrinsic value over and •above the actual value of the property of the corporation which they stand for and represent; and the assessment and taxation of such shares, and also all the corporate property, would be double taxation. Therefore, all property belonging to corporations, save and except the property of national banking •associations not assessable by federal statute, shall be assessed and ta;red. But no assessment shall be made of shares of stock in any corporation, save and except in national banking associations, whose property, other than real •estate, is exempt from assessment by federal statute.

“3609.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.