Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit December 2, 1902, No. 1,069 (York Mfg. Co. v. Rothwell)
Also known as
United States · · · 02-12-1902
SEVERENS, Circuit Judge,
having made the foregoing statement of the case, delivered the opinion of the court.
There are a great number of assignments of error, but counsel for the plaintiff have simplified the points for review by substantially limiting the discussion to the first three, which are as follows:
“(1) The court erred in overruling the plaintiff’s objection to admission of any evidence in support of the defendant’s answer and counterclaim. (2) In overruling the plaintiff’s motion, made at the close of the evidence offered in chief by the defendant, to direct the jury to return a verdict in favor of the plaintiff, and in overruling the said motion when the same was again renewed at the close of the evidence offered by the plaintiff, and at the close of that offered by the defendant in rebuttal. (3) In refusing to charge the jury as requested by the plaintiff in his request No. 1, which was as follows: ‘(1) Under the evidence in this case, the defendant is not entitled to a recovery of the claim set forth in his cross-petition, and your verdict should be for the plaintiff jfor the amount claimed in the amended petition.’ ”
These propositions are, however, resolvable into two: First, whether the counterclaim was maintainable at all; and, second, whether the evidence given in support of it was sufficient to justify the verdict which established it.
Before proceeding to- the discussion of these questions, it should be noted that although the cross-petition speaks of the purchasers .of the plant as if they were joint purchasers, simply, the contract offered in evidence shows that it was made by them.as partners under the firm name of Rothwell & Lovett. But no” question of variance was raised at any time in the court below, and, under the practice of the courts of Ohio, the variance would in such case be disregarded, and the verdict and judgment would be such as the evidence requires.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit