U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Eastern Pennsylvania April 21, 1902, No. 65 (Glencove Granite Co. v. City Trust, Safe Deposit & Surety Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 21-04-1902

J. B. McPHERSON, District Judge.

The questions presented upon the trial of this case were (with one exception) precisely those that were passed upon by the circuit court of appeals in the opinion reported in 113 P'ed., at page 177. The defendant added nothing essential to the record that was then before the court of appeals, and the plaintiff offered one additional paper only, about which I shall speak in a moment. Since, therefore, the court of appeals has decided that the record then presented to that court disclosed a prima facie defense, and since the recent trial of the case before me did not explain or remove the apparent obstacle to recovery which the decision declared to exist, it seems to me to follow inevitably that the prima facies must prevail, and that the defendant is entitled to judgment. My own opinion was different, and, if I may say so respectfully, still is different; but, of course, I obey cheerfully the ruling of the appellate tribunal.

The defendant, therefore, is entitled to judgment on the reserved point, unless the paper to which I have referred as having been offered in evidence by the plaintiff ought to lead to a contrary conclusion. This was a certificate, dated February 18, 1897, from the office of the secretary of state of New York, and is as follows:

“State of New York, Office of the Secretary of State, Albany.

“It is hereby certified, that Glencove Granite Company, which appears from the papers filed in this office on the 18th day of February. 1897, to be a foreign stock corporation organized and existing under the laws of the state of Maine, has complied with all the requirements of law to authorize it to do business in this state, and that the business of such corporation to be carried on in this state is such as may be lawfully carried on by a corporation incorporated under the laws of this state for such or similar business.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.