Supreme Court of the United States March 24, 1902, 508 (Tulare Irrigation District v. Shepard)
Also known as
United States · · · 24-03-1902
Mr. Justice Beckham,
after making the foregoing statement of facts, delivered the opinion of the court.
*8
It is agreed in the statement of facts in this case that the moneys received from the sale of the bonds in suit were applied to building and constructing the irrigation works now in use by the defendant corporation. It has, therefore, received the full consideration for which the bonds were issued, has built its works'with the proceeds, and uses such works for the purposes intended. • Notwithstanding these “facts, it now refuses to pay the bonds or the interest thereon, and, while acting as a corporation, at all times, still sets up that it was never .legally organized, and hence had no legal right to issue any bonds.
In the case of
Douglas County Commissioners
v. Bolles, 94 U. S; 104, 110, a case involving facts somewhat similar, this court said: “ Common honesty demands that a debt thus incurred should be paid.” That sentiment has lost no force by the lapse of time, and we think it applies in its full strength to this case. • Unless there be some settled rule of law which prevents a recovery in this action, the judgment under review should be affirmed.
The sole ground of defence which has been urged at the bar has been an alleged defect in the notice of the intended presentation of the petition to form the district, to the board of supervisors, the defect consisting in the omission to add. at the end of the notice the names of' the signers to the petition which immediately precedes it. ■
Section two of the act approved March 7, 1887, commonly called the “ Wright Act ” óf the California legislature, provides that the petition for the organization of an irrigation district shall be pres'ente'd tcuthe board of supervisors of.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit