Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York July 1, 1903 (Meyer v. Supreme Lodge, Knights of Pythias)
Also known as
United States · · · 01-07-1903
Goodrich, P. J.:
The plaintiff, being the beneficiary named in a membership certificate issued upon the application of her husband, Emanuel Meyer, by the defendant, a fraternal mutual benefit corporation, sues for the amount of insurance on the life of her husband specified in the certificate. The defense was that Meyer had committed suicide, which by the terms of the certificate renders it null and void.
When the case came on for trial before Mr. Justice Gaynor and a jury, the defendant claimed and obtained the affirmative of the *360issue .and introduced its evidence, and the plaintiff introduced evidence in rebuttal. At the close of the whole evidence, the defendant moved for a dismissal of the complaint, “ upon the- ground that, the plaintiff had. not shown compliance, with-the terms of the contract, by showing.she, had put in proper and complete proofs of death, as provided by the by-laws and the contract.” The court: properly denied the motion on the ground that the defendant, at the opening of the case, had “ claimed the affirmative and admitted that all the conditions precedent had been complied with, therefore,, the plaintiff did not need to .put in any such proof,” The court submitted to the jury for special verdict.the question: Did Emanuel Meyer, the husband of the plaintiff, commit suicide % And the jury haying answered the question no, the court directed judgment for the amount of the policy, and the jury found a verdict accordingly. The defendant moved to set aside the verdict; the motion was. denied and the defendant excepted and appeals.
. The only question which we are required'to consider is the exception to a refusal to admit the testimony of three physicians who-attended Meyer, as to declarations concerning the cause of his death made by hiin in their presence. Plaintiff’s counsel objected to their admission on the.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit