Appellate Terms of the Supreme Court of New York May 15, 1903 (Frankfurt v. Weir)
Also known as
United States · · · 15-05-1903
Freedman, P. J.
This action was brought to recover from the defendant, as president of the Adams Express Company, the sum of $142.50, the value of one of two packages delivered by the plaintiffs to the Adams Express Company, and to be transported by it to J. N. Barrel, at Ardmore, Ind. Ter., U. S. A. The plaintiffs claim that one of said packages was never delivered. The trial of the issues resulted in a judgment for the plaintiffs for fifty dollars, from which both parties appeal.
At the time of shipment the plaintiffs had in their possession a book of receipts of the defendant company. One of these was filled out and signed by an employee of the defendant company and retained by the plaintiffs. It contained no special insurance nor greater valuation of the property than the sum of fifty dollars, and provided that said sum should in any event constitute the limit of the liability of the company. The receipt contained the identical clauses which were contained in the receipt discussed in the case of Bernstein v. Levi C. Weir, as president of the Adams Express Co., decided at present term of this court (40 Misc. Rep. 635), and to which reference should be made for further particulars. Under the decision of that case the receipt constituted a special contract, and under such contract the defendant in the present case has the right to insist that in no event is his liability to exceed the sum of fifty dollars. The consequence is that, even if the plaintiffs prove their alleged cause of action, the judgment was properly rendered in their favor for only fifty dollars, and their appeal is without merit.
On defendant’s appeal it is contended that the plaintiffs did *684not prove a .cause of action (1) by failing to prove nondelivery; and (2) by failing to prove compliance with the thirty-day clause of the contract.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit