Supreme Court of Arkansas October 24, 1903 (Myar v. St. Louis Southwestern Railway Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 24-10-1903

Battle, J.

On the 12th of April, 1900, Henry W. Myar brought an action against the St. Louis Southwestern Eailway Company to recover the possession of certain 196 bales of cotton, which he alleged that the defendant held without right. The defendant answered, denying the plaintiff’s right of possession, and alleging as follows: “That it is entitled to the possession thereof because it then had the same in its possession as a common carrier, having shipped the same from Waldo, Arkansas, to shipper’s orders, for which service it had a lien on said cotton for its freight charges, amounting to $241.64, which charges were not paid nor tendered before the institution of this suit, nor before the service of said order of delivery; nor did the plaintiff deliver up nor tender the bill of lading for said cotton, they being consigned to the shipper’s orders, before the institution of this suit or the service of said writ of possession or order of delivery.”

To this answer the plaintiff replied as follows: “That he denied that defendant had a lien on the cotton mentioned in the complaint for the sum of $240.64, as common carrier or otherwise, but alleges the truth to be that plaintiff contracted with defendant as a common carrier to transport said cotton from Waldo, Arkansas, to Camden, Arkansas, for the agreed price of $-, to be paid defendant on the deliver}1- of said cotton to him at Camden. That on the arrival of said cotton at Camden, plaintiff tendered to said defendant in lawful money of the United States the sum of $66.66, the same being the full amount for which defendant agreed to transport and deliver said cotton at Camden, and demanded of the defendant the delivery of the cotton, which was refused. And plaintiff here brings into court and deposits for the benefit of defendant the said sum of $-. Plaintiff says that at the time of said demand the defendant waived the delivery of the bill of lading when plaintiff ordered it.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.