Missouri Court of Appeals February 18, 1903 (Union Trust Co. v. Soderer)

Also known as

United States · · · 18-02-1903

VALLIANT, J.

During a contest of the alleged • will of Alois Soderer, the plaintiff was appointed by the probate court administrator pendente lite of the estate. This suit was begun in-the circuit court by the plaintiff in that capacity to recover of the defendants personal property and real estate which the petition alleges belonged to the estate and came into the hands of defendants as trustees under the will.

The petition alleges that personal property of the value of $5,800 belonging to the estate, was turned over to the defendants by the executrix before the plaintiff’s appointment as administrator pendente lite, and is now *678held by them, and also several parcels of real estate which are rented and from which the defendants are collecting rents to the amount of $1,000 a month; that defendants claim the right to hold this personal property and real estate and collect their rents by virtue of the will under which they are appointed trustees; that plaintiff has demanded possession of the personal property and real estate and an account of the rents collected, but defendants have refused to render the same. The prayer is for a decree for possession, an accounting, an injunction from interfering with plaintiff’s management of the estate, etc. Defendants demurred to the petition, the court sustained the demurrer and plaintiff declined to plead further. There was a final judgment for defendants, and the plaintiff appeals.

The plaintiff is of course entitled to possession of all the personal property belonging to the estate. The petition alleges that before the plaintiff’s appointment the executrix turned over to the defendants personal property belonging to the estate of the value of $5,800, and that defendants still hold the same. But the petition does not state of what that personalty consisted, and therefore there is no issue tendered as to personal property.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.