Court of Appeals for the Fifth Circuit March 3, 1903, No. 1,200 (The Yarkand)

Also known as

United States · · · 03-03-1903

MEEK, District Judge,

after stating the facts as above, delivered the opinion of the court.

The appellants complain that the trial court erred in holding as matter of law on the facts found that there existed such a necessity *891as justified the master in selling the ship without first communicating with and securing the authority of the owners. They do not challenge the correctness of the facts found by the district judge, but by the phrasing of the assignment of errors and in their argument and briefs they tacitly admit the sufficiency of the evidence to support his findings. We have read the record carefully, and have concluded that, though the testimony as to the condition and peril of the ship is conflicting, yet it sustains the findings of the district judge, and, consequently, they will not be disturbed. The Albany (C. C.) 48 Fed. 565; The Alijandro, 6 C. C. A. 54, 56 Fed. 622.

The principles involved in the disposition of this case are few, and well settled. Both sides to the controversy cite the same authorities in support of their respective contentions, so that it is manifest the difficulty lies in the application of recognized principles to the facts. It is settled law that a master has no general authority, virtute officii, to sell his vessel. The Catherine, 15 Jur. 1 Eng. Law & Eq. 679; Gates v. Thompson, 57 Me. 422, 99 Am. Dec. 782; 20 A. & E. of Law, Second Ed. 210. It is as well settled that a master has implied authority to sell his vessel in case of actual necessity; but there must be an extreme necessity, and the master must have acted in good faith, to render the sale made by him valid. The Amelie, 6 Wall. 26, 18 L. Ed. 806; The Brig Sarah Ann, 2 Sumn. 206, Fed. Cas. No. 12,342; Id., 13 Pet. 400, 10 L. Ed. 213. Mr. Justice Davis, in The Amelie, cited supra, says:

“The sale of a ship becomes a necessity, within the meaning of the commercial law, when nothing better can be done for the owner, or those concerned in the adventure.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.