Court of Appeals for the Sixth Circuit March 18, 1903, No. 1,129 (In re Muhlhauser)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-03-1903
SEVERENS, Circuit Judge,
after making the preceding statement, delivered the opinion of the court.
We think the position taken by the learned counsel for the petitioners is quite correct to the extent that it is claimed that, if the proposed petition presents a matter properly cognizable by the bankruptcy court, ■ the orderly course would have been to allow it to be filed, leaving the final adjudication upon its merits to be settled upon full inquiry; with this reservation, however, that, if the case as made by the petition is manifestly frivolous or wanting all color of claim for the relief sought, the court might properly decline to entertain an idle controversy, such as the case supposed would be. We do not, however, think it indispensably necessary to express a definite opinion upon the question whether this petition, properly construed, is of the character last mentioned, because we agree that the order of the District Court was right, for the reason the petition presented issues and sought relief beyond the proper jurisdiction of the bankruptcy court; although we incline to the view that no ground for any relief within the power.of the court is shown. The controversy proposed to be brought on was one peculiarly the subject of the jurisdiction of a court of equity, where all the parties interested might be brought in, and the whole subject determined upon plenary procedure. The petitioners were strangers to the proceedings, and other necessary parties, notably the executrix of Frederick Muhlhauser’s will, were not present, nor could they then properly be brought in to litigate, with other strangers, questions of general equity in the District Court. The primary function of that court, when sitting in bankruptcy, is that of administration. It takes possession of the bankrupt’s assets for that purpose. Of necessity, it must have and exercise such incidental jurisdiction as pertains to a court which takes exclusive possession and. control of property.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit