District Court, S.D. New York June 1, 1903 (Morse Ironworks & Dry Dock Co. v. Luckenbach)

Also known as

United States · · · 01-06-1903

ADAMS, District Judge.

This is a motion on the part of Lewis Luckenbach, the cross-libellant, to stay the libellant’s proceedings until it shall, as respondent in the cross-libel, give security for the damages claimed in the cross-libel.

The action is in personam to recover from Luckenbach (i) a balance of $950, claimed to be due for work, &c., on the steamship “Saale,” and (2) a balance of $34,803.45 claimed to be due for work, &c., on the steamship “Styria.”

The defences seem to be, (1) an offset claimed to amount to $800 for damages arising from delay in performing the work upon the Saale, and, (2) a denial that $34,803.45 was the balance due on the Styria and a claimed offset of $22,100 for damages arising from delay in performing the wo?k upon her and a further sum of $248.98 for materials furnished the libellant, making a total claimed offset of $22,348.98, as opposed to the libellant’s claim of $34,803.45, which is denied to be correct, but what balance is due, apart from the offset, is not stated.

It is urged by the cross-libellant that he is entitled to security under Admiralty Rule 53, which provides:

“Whenever a cross-libel is filed upon any counterclaim, arising out of the same cause of action for which the original libel was filed, the respondents in the cross-libel shall give security in the usual amount and form, to respond in damages, as claimed in said cross-libel, unless the court, on cause shown, shall otherwise direct; and all proceedings upon the original libel shall be stayed until such security shall be given.”

The argument advanced is, that the rule provides alike for actions in rem and in personam and that, therefore, in the latter class of actions, notwithstanding the libellant has no security for his claim, the respondent can stay the proceedings until security be given to him. The following cases have been referred to me in support of the contention, viz.: The Steamer Bristol, Fed. Cas. No. 1,889, 4 Ben.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.