U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Northern New York November 17, 1903 (N. K. Fairbanks Co. v. Dunn)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-11-1903

' RAY, District Judge.

The papers in this case show, and the court finds, that the complainant has a product known as Gold Dust, and has a valid registered trade-mark “Gold Dust,” which has been generally acquiesced in and also adjudicated in favor of the complainant. The class of merchandise to which this trade-mark is appropriated is cleansing and polishing preparations, and the particular description of goods comprised in such class, on which said corporation uses said trade-mark, is detergent and washing powders. This trade-mark has been used continuously by said corporation in its business since June 5, 1887. Gold Dust is a useful article, and has met and meets with a large sale, and this trade-mark is of great value to the complainant. The words “Gold Dust” have become invested with a particular and a secondary meaning, as indicating and designating a washing powder made and sold by the complainant.

The defendant, John F. Dunn, is conducting and transacting the business of a grocer at Little Falls, Rome, and Utica, in the state *228of New York. In his said business he has advertised Gold Dust, and has advertised to sell the same at a less price than the same can be obtained and sold for at a profit in the market. Having so advertised Gold Dust, the defendant has on several occasions knowingly and willfully and fraudulently handed out and delivered to his customers who called for Gold Dust, and who desired to purchase Gold Dust, and who expected they were purchasing and obtaining Gold Dust, another and inferior article known as Buffalo, and in so doing has not only imposed upon and defrauded purchasers to their damage and injury, but has injured the complainant.

The defendant claim's that he was ignorant of this act, but the court cannot so find. The defendant claims that he has had no purpose to deliver to customers the soap powder Buffalo when Gold Dust has been called for. The court is not satisfied that such is the fact.

The acts complained of are unlawful.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.