Court of Appeals of Maryland January 20, 1904 (Baltimore & Potomac Railroad v. Jean)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-01-1904
Page, -J.,
delivered the opinion of the Court.
This is an action to recover-for injuries received by the appellee, while a passenger on the train of the appellant. The
*547
appeal is from the rulings of the lower Court upon the prayers, of which the Court granted the two offered by the appellee, and the fourth, seventh and eighth of the appellant; and refused its first, second, third, fifth and sixth.
By the first, second and third prayers of the appellant, the following questions are raised; 1st. Is there any evidence of negligence on the part of the appellant, 2nd. Did such negligence cause the injuries complained of, and 3rd, was the appellee guilty of contributory negligence. These three prayers respectively are to the effect that there is no evidence in the case, sufficient to legally establish any of these matters; and therefore the verdict of the jury should be for the appellant.
First,
is there any evidence legally sufficient of negligence on the part of the appellant?
The appellee was a passenger on the train of the appellant, on his way from Washington to Baltimore. He proposed to leave the train at Pennsylvania avenue, a station, situated at an opening in the tunnel. This opening is three hundred and thirty-two feet long. The station platform is at the bottom of a deep cut and runs the entire length of the opening. The train consisted of a locomotive, a baggage car, a sn.oker and two ladies coaches in the rear. The evidence of the manner in which the accident happened, relied on by the appellee to sustain his view of the case, may be briefly stated as follows. As the train approached the station, the conductor came in the smoking car, where the appellee was seated, and cried out “all out for Pennsylvania Avenue station.” His manner was hurried—“he had a hustle on.” He passed through the car after giving this warning twice, and went out of the rear of the car. The appellee then rose and passed down the aisle.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit