Texas Supreme Court June 2, 1904, No. 1322. (Gulf, Colorado & Santa Fe Railway Co. v. Johnson)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-06-1904

WILLIAMS, Associate Justice.

We are of the opinion that the trial court erred in sustaining plaintiff’s objection to the competency of the witness Mangone, based upon his conviction of theft from the person. To establish by such a fact the incompetency of a witness, a record showing a conviction must be produced. That which was produced was only the judgment of the District Court based upon a verdict. If that which is called the judgment in our criminal procedure were, in its legal effect, the same as a judgment of conviction at common law, it would constitute the proper evidence of conviction. But at common law the judgment was the final act of the court adjudging the guilt and included that which we treat separately as the sentence. It was pronounced after the court had heard what the accused could say in bar of it, and, when it had been rendered, the sanction of both the court and jury was given to the conviction. 4 Black., chap. 29, p. 376. Under our procedure, the judgment is entered as a matter of course upon the return of the verdict. Code Crim. Proc., 756-757. While, in case of conviction, it adjudges the accused to be guilty and fixes the punishment, this is merely the consequence of the verdict, and the court in rendering it finally determines nothing as to the sufficiency of the procedure and evidence to justify a conviction. It is entered subject i:o the right of the accused to move in arrest of the judgment and for a new trial, and to interpose reasons against the pronouncing of sentence. It is therefore necessarily true that the judicial action of the court, finally establishing the conviction, takes place after the entry of what we call the judgment and when sentence is recorded. It is only then that the whole record has the legal effect of the common law record of conviction, and it follows that this is the record by which conviction is to be proved.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.