New York Supreme Court December 15, 1904 (Reese v. City of Johnstown)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-12-1904

Kellogg, John M., J.

The plaintiffs and their predecessors in title have for years been sewering from their three houses and shop or mill into the Cuyadutta creek, and the ancestor of the plaintiffs, from whom they derive title, formerly owned a skin mill near their present property which also sewered into the creek. The city of Johnstown sewers into the same creek, as does the city of Gloversville above upon the stream, and various skin mills and privies drain into the stream along its course, and garbage and foul matter of all kinds are thrown into it. The plaintiffs bring this action under section 1660 of the Code to compel the city to stop sewering _into the stream and to recover damages against it. It does not appear whether the city or the plaintiffs and their predecessors in title first began fouling the stream. The city and all the owners along the stream have the right to make any reasonable use of it, but must not divert or pollute it to the detriment of the lower proprietors. What is a reasonable use depends upon the particular circumstances and the use which is made of the stream by the proprietors below. “ The judge was careful to say that the failure to put that land to any benefieial use was no defense to an unreasonable and improper use of the stream by the defendants, but that the fact might be considered in determining whether defendants’ use of the stream was reasonable and proper. In the course of the trial the plaintiff, through his counsel, disclaimed any *434right to recover substantial" damages. The relief sought was a permanent injunction. In deciding whether this drastic remedy should be applied it was the duty of the .court to ascertain whether defendants’ use of the stream was reasonable or not.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.