Supreme Court of Pennsylvania April 11, 1904, Appeal, No. 293 (Hyman v. Tilton)
Also known as
United States · · · 11-04-1904
Opinion by
Mr. Justice Dean,
Julius Hyman, a boy about ten years old with a number of other boys of the same age was going from school along Race street in the direction of Third about four o’clock in the afternoon of December 13, 1900, when they attempted to get on a four wheeled truck going in the same direction. The truck was loaded, had standards at the side connected by chains and the driver sat on a high seat in front. Two of the boys got up on the truck from behind. At Third street it stopped for a passing car and then Hyman climbed up at the side between the wheels to the body of the truck and stood with one foot on an iron bar, holding on by his hands to one of the standards. He had his satchel filled with school books which he was taking home with him. As soon as the car passed the driver of the truck started up his horses at a slow trot and immediately after starting called to the boys to get off. Those on the hind end of the truck did so; Hyman, in an apparently perilous position between the wheels of the truck did not at once obey *643and the driver lashed him more than once around the legs with his whip; the lash at the last stroke apparently wrapped itself around the boy’s leg or caught in the laces of his shoe so that in drawing it back the boy’s foot slipped from the bar or he became frightened and fell off ; the wagon passed over his leg so crushing it that amputation was necessary. The plaintiff alleging negligence brought this suit for damages; there was a verdict for plaintiff and'defendant appeals, assigning for error the submission under the pleadings of the evidence to the jury. Under this specification all that is worthy of notice can be discussed.
It is alleged that the allegata and probata do not agree and that the variance is so wide that under the law a verdict cannot be sustained.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit