Superior Court of Pennsylvania July 28, 1904, Appeal, No. 93 (Pennsylvania Mining Co. v. Naomi Coal Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-07-1904

Opinion by

Beaver, J.,

From Harvey v. Thomas, 10 Watts, 63, in which the lateral railroad Act of May 5, 1832, P. L. 501, was declared to be constitutional, to Frick Coke Co. v. Painter, 198 Pa. 468, in which it was held that “ the necessity for a lateral railroad on the route selected by the petitioner is a question for the jury under proper instructions by the court,” through more than a score of cases, the said act has received careful consideration and a construction of its provisions and a determination of the questions which are likely to arise under it, so that little remains for us, except to apply the principles of these cases to the one under consideration.

The subject in general is fully discussed in the charge of the trial judge in the court below and with the general features of that charge no fault is found.

The assignments of error rest within a very narrow compass and all practically relate to the necessity of the road.

It appears from the evidence that the defendant, after the viewers appointed by the court had assessed the damages and made their report thereon and an appeal had been taken by the plaintiffs, constructed a temporary road by a roundabout way operated by various devices and different sorts of motive power, so as to enable them to reach the terminus ad quid of their originally projected line. The plaintiff contended that, by this construction of a roundabout road or system of roads, by which the defendant accomplished the object originally intended, the necessity for the route laid out over the plaintiff’s land was obviated and the defendant estopped from asserting its necessity.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.