Supreme Court of Kansas January 9, 1904, No. 13,404 (Metropolitan Street-railway Co. v. O'Neill)

Also known as

United States · · · 09-01-1904

The opinion of the court was delivered by

CunNinghaM, J. :

Plaintiff below brought this action to recover his damages resultant upon personal injuries inflicted by reason of the negligence of the defendant. As elements of such damages he claimed actual expenses as follows: $65, hospital bill; $258, doctor bill; $175, medicines and other incidental expenses ; $1000, for loss of time. The balance of $8450 was the total amount claimed for his suffering and permanent injury. The jury returned a verdict of $800. . Upon the plaintiff’s motion this was set aside and a new trial granted, the court giving the following reason therefor : “ Because the verdict is not sustained by sufficient evidence, and is contrary to law, in this, that the verdict is too small, the same not being equal in amount to the actual pecuniary inj ury to plaintiff, as shown by the evidence.”

The record discloses that the plaintiff expended the amounts claimed for actual expenses, a total sum of $498. The value of the time which he lost was not established by evidence which gave to the jury any adequate basis to determine the same. Indeed, the evidence upon this point required the allowance of little more than a nominal amount, it showing only that the plaintiff at the time of his injury was, and had been for about two weeks before, engaged in the manufacture of vinegar, the value of the business de*254pending upon the profits; that he was detained from the business a year; that his share of the profits during the two weeks before the accident would amount to about seventy-five dollars per month ; that the value of the services of a person to take his place and do the work which he had been performing was seventy-five dollars per month.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.