Court of Appeals of Texas October 28, 1905 (Tracy v. Harbin)

Also known as

United States · · · 28-10-1905

*396

SPEER, Associate Justice.

This was an injunction suit instituted by the appellees against appellants to restrain the sale upon execution of a quarter section of land situated in Eastland County, alleged to be the homestead of appellee A. W. Harbin. Upon a finding by the trial judge in favor of the homestead exemption, the temporary injunction was made permanent and appellants have brought the case before us for review.

- We construe the instrument of writing, under which appellee claims his homestead interest, to be a conveyance in fee simple with condition subsequent, and therefore ample support for his homestead claim. But if it were not, his equitable interest would undoubtedly be sufficient to support such a claim, title to the fee in such case not being absolutely" essential. (Dotson v. Barnett, 16 Texas Civ. App., 258; 41 S. W. Rep., 99; Smith v. Chenault, 48 Texas, 455; Silverman v. Landrum, 56 S. W. Rep., 107; Swearingen v. Bassett, 65 Texas, 267; Speer, Law of Married Women, sec. 252.) The seventh assignment of error, complaining that appellee presents no title sufficient to support the homestead claim, is therefore overruled.

The eighth assignment of error insists that the facts show an abandonment of the homestead by appellee prior to the levy of appellants’ execution, and complains that the court therefore erred in perpetuating the injunction forbidding its sale. The statement from appellants’ brief, which is in no manner controverted by appellees, requires us to sustain this assignment. Appellee A. W. Harbin lived on the land in controversy with one" or both of his parents from 1888 until 1901. He married in April, 1896, by which union he had four living children on November 10, 1901. During the year 1901, he learned of the opening up for settlement of the lands of the United States in Oklahoma Territory. He made three trips to the territory and on July 11, 1901, drew Claim No. 1000.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.