Supreme Court of Arkansas January 14, 1905 (LaFayette v. Merchants' Bank)

Also known as

United States · · · 14-01-1905

Riddick, J.,

(after stating the facts.) This is an action to recover money páid under mistake of fact. And the facts, briefly stated, are that one Boudinot Whitlock had an agreement with the plaintiffs, RaFayette & Brother, by which RaFayette & Brother agreed to pay drafts drawn by Whitlock on them for the purchase price of cattle, provided that a bill of sale signed by the vendor conveying the cattle to RaFayette & Brother should be indorsed on the back of the draft as security for the payment of the draft. . To enable Whitlock to have these drafts with bill of sale in proper form, blank drafts with bills of sale printed on the back, with spaces for description of cattle purchased and for signature of the owner, were prepared and given to Whitlock. The intention was that he should buy these cattle in the Indian Territory, where he lived, and where the firm of RaFayette & Brother was in business. He afterwards drew drafts in favor of certain parties living in the Territory without their knowledge, and then without their knowledge or consent indorsed their names on the back of the drafts, and signed their names to the bills of sale on the back of the drafts, and then delivered the drafts to the Merchants’ Bank, of Fort Smith, which paid him full value therefor. The bank indorsed the draft, and sent it to a 'bank at Muskogee, Ind. Ter., which presented it to RaFayette & Brother for payment, and they paid it. Neither the Merchants’ Bank nor RaFayette & Brother had any notice of the forgery, and both supposed that it was a legitimate transaction on the part of Whitlock. On the discovery of the fraud, RaFayette & Brother demanded that the bank repay the money, and upon its refusal to do so they brought this action to recover it.

It is a general rule that money paid under a mistake of fact may be recovered.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.