Supreme Court of Vermont January 26, 1905 (State v. Atkins)

Also known as

United States · · · 26-01-1905

Watson, J.

The respondent was trjed for a breach of the peace and found guilty. The breach of the peace claimed by the State was that the respondent intentionally drove his wagon against the carriage in which Mrs. Hattie Matthews, the prosecuting witness, was riding in the public highway, whereby she was thrown out and injured. The respondent’s evidence tended to show that Mrs. Matthews was responsible for the collision, and that she intentionally ran against the respondent’s wagon to do him- injury, or that on account .of the conduct of her horse, and her fast and careless way of driving it, she ran into the respondent’s wagon, and that he was not in any way guilty of the offence charged. The respondent claimed that as far as he was concerned the collision was a pure accident, and he disclaimed having acted in self-defence.

The State was permitted to show, subject to> exception, that the respondent on an occasion when he was passing Mrs. Matthews prior to the time of the alleged offence, made a threat -against her to the effect that he would some day run into- her. This evidence was properly received. Prior threats of an accused are relevant as showing his mental attitude toward the prosecuting witness at the time of the assault, unless after the making of the threats and before the assault, the parties become friends. State v. Heun, 39 Minn. 476; La Beau v. People, 34 N. Y. 223. Such threats are also evidence tending to make it more probable that the accused committed the act complained of. Whart. Cr. Ev. § 756; Stokes *218v. People, 53 N. Y. 164; State v. Bradley, 64 Vt. 466, 24 Atl. 1053.

The respondent offered evidence of threats of violence made against him by the prosecuting witness on several different occasions previous to the collision, as showing her animosity toward him, and as tending to show that she was the aggressor, and also that she intended to run into him. This evidence was excluded, to which respondent excepted.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.