Illinois Supreme Court December 20, 1905 (Landt v. McCullough)
Also known as
United States · · · 20-12-1905
Mr. Justice Wilkin
delivered the opinion of the court:
It is first insisted by counsel for appellants that the lease in question was improperly admitted in evidence because it contained certain erasures, interlineations and alterations which were not properly explained. Appellee testified that all of these erasures, interlineations and alterations were made before the lease was signed, and that it was in the same condition when it was offered in evidence that it was when it was signed by the parties; that two copies of it were made at the time of its execution, one being retained by Stebbins and the other by himself; that Stebbins had paid rent under the lease from 1889 until it was assigned, in 1892; that at the timé of the assignment one copy was given to the appellants and one copy retained by him, and a copy was filed for record in the recorder’s office of Cook county; that appellants paid rent under the assignment until November 1, 1900. This evidence was clearly sufficient to explain any erasures, interlineations or alterations in the instrument, and as the evidence was not contradicted in any way, the court committed no error in admitting the instrument in evidence.
It is next insisted that the evidence does not show that the lease was accepted by James M. Stebbins at the time it was made or that the appellants entered into possession under the assignment. Again, the testimony of appellee shows that the instrument was drawn by Stebbins and the alterations were made by him. He paid rent under it for several years, and then assigned it, under his hand and seal, to appellants. After all of these acts it is difficult to see how it can seriously be contended that he did not accept the lease. Nor do we see how it can be claimed, under the evidence, that the appellants did not enter into possession of the prem- . ises under the assignment. The assignment was special and specifically named the appellants.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit