Illinois Supreme Court December 20, 1905 (Creighton v. Roe)

Also known as

United States · · · 20-12-1905

Mr. Justice Wilkin

delivered the opinion of the court:

It is first claimed as a ground of reversal that the deed was never delivered by plaintiff in error, and that this is evidenced by the fact that he always retained the possession of the same, together with the property conveyed. The question as to what acts are necessary to constitute a sufficient delivery to render a deed operative and to pass the title to land has been the subject of much discussion in this court. The deed may be delivered to the grantee or to his agent. No particular form or ceremony is necessary to constitute such a delivery. It may be by acts or words or both, or by one without the other; but what is said or done must clearly manifest the intention of the grantor and of the grantee that the deed shall at once become operative to pass the title to the land conveyed and that the grantor shall lose all control over the deed. (Byars v. Spencer, 101 Ill. 429.) The question of delivery is one both of law and of fact. From the details of such facts and attending circumstances is to be determined the legal question as to whether such acts and declarations constitute a legal delivery. (Shults v. Shults, 159 Ill. 654.) In cases of voluntary settlement the law makes stronger presumptions in favor of the delivery than in any ordinary case of bargain and sale, for the reason that it is an attempt on the part of the grantor to make a settlement. (Bryan v. Wash, 2 Gilm. 557; Cline v. Jones, 111 Ill. 563.) Such settlements, fairly made, are binding on the grantor unless there be clear and decisive proof that he never parted or intended to part with the possession of the deed, and if he retained it the weight of authority is decidedly in favor of its validity, unless there are other circumstances besides the mere fact of his retaining it to show that it was not intended to be absolute. (Shults v. Shults, supra; Otis v. Beckwith, 49 Ill. 121; Perry on Trusts, sec. 103.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.