Montana Supreme Court March 18, 1905, No. 1,697 (Forrester v. Boston & Montana Consolidated Copper & Silver Mining Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 18-03-1905
lead-opinion
MR. JUSTICE MILBURN
delivered the opinion of the court.
This case has come before us on motion for rehearing, the former opinion appearing in 30 Mont. 181, 16 Pac. 2.
After consideration of the motion for rehearing the same is denied, a rehearing not being necessary. But of our own motion we have taken the case up for reconsideration, and we have concluded that the decision and opinion rendered after the original hearing, and referred to above, should be modified. The only point in the motion for rehearing worthy of consideration is that made as to the compensation of the receiver.
In the former opinion we said: “Inasmuch as the receiver should have been, in justice, discharged certainly as early as April 5, 1898 [1899], when the defendants offered, in writing, to do the very things that the plaintiffs prayed to have done by decree of court, we hold that he may be compensated in a reasonable sum for services rendered by him prior to said last-mentioned date, and be reimbursed for all proper and reasonable expenses incurred prior thereto, and that he receive nothing and be allowed nothing for any services or expenses alleged to have been rendered or incurred after that date out of the property of the defendants, excepting, possibly, a reasonable sum for the services of a bookkeeper aiding in rendition ■of accounts to the court.” After further consultation, we conclude that the position of the receiver is correct in part. As he says, and as we say in the first opinion herein, the appointment of the receiver was, in 1900, held by this court to be valid. He was lawfully and properly appointed. If the defendants had not done the things complained of by the plaintiffs, then the receiver would not have been asked for, and any action of the conrt would not have been needed.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit