U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Northern New York May 18, 1905, No. 7,026 (Van Epps v. United Box Board & Paper Co.)

RAY, District Judge.

This is a suit in equity for an injunction and an accounting, based on the alleged infringement by defendant of what is known as the Victory letters patent, No. 417,451, dated December 17, 1889. The defenses set up and urged are “noninfringement, lack of patentable subject-matter,” and “anticipation by prior patents and publications, as set up in the answer.