Court of Appeals of Texas June 13, 1906 (Pirtle v. Nell)

Also known as

United States · · · 13-06-1906

EIDSON, Associate Justice.

There is no legal statement of facts embraced in or sent up with the record in this cause. There is a paper sent up with but separate from the transcript in this cause, endorsed “statement of facts,” and, after giving the style and number of the case, beginning as follows: “Be it remembered that upon the trial of the above styled and numbered causé, the following were the facts and all the facts proven.” Then follows a statement of the testimony taken upon the trial, including documentary and oral, and at the end of the statement is the word “approved,” and under that is the signature and official character of the trial judge.

*419

At the time of the trial and the preparation of tliis document the Act of the Twenty-ninth Legislature was in effect, which provides that the official stenographer’s transcript of the oral evidence adduced upon the trial of the case, after being submitted to the interested parties for any objection thereto, and being found to be correct and approved by the trial judge, should constitute the statement of facts of the oral evidence in the case; and also provides that any original documentary evidence, sketches, maps, plats or other matters introduced in evidence, and if embraced in the stenographer’s report, may be made a part of the record of said cause by written direction of the court, which may be sent up in the original form, if required by either party to the suit, or transcribed by the clerk with other parts of the record therein. (Acts 29th Leg. Reg. Sess.. p. 219.) It does not appear from this paper that it is the official stenographer’s transcript of the evidence; neither does it appear that same was submitted to the interested parties for their objections, nor that the documentary evidence was embraced in such transcript by the direction of the court.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.