Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York November 5, 1906 (Morris v. Wucher)
Also known as
United States · · · 05-11-1906
lead-opinion
Ingraham, J.:
The plaintiffs’ testator died in the year 1905, leaving a last will and testament of which the plaintiffs were executors. He was a member of the church of St. Vincent de Paul in the city of New York. In the year. 1896 he paid to the defendant, one of the clergymen connected with that church, $4,000. The defendant paid to the testator during his lifetime interest upon that sum at four per cent. The only testimony as to the circumstances under which that money was paid was the evidence of the defendant, who testified: “ Mr. De Comps gave me the $4,000 in 1896, when I *279needed money for church decorations. He said to pay him interest during his lifetime, to dispose of afterwards according to his instructions which he would leave in a private letter.” This evidence was read by the plaintiffs from a deposition of the defendant Wucher before the surrogate.
I think the effect of this transaction was that there was paid to the defendant a sum of money upon a contract by which the defendant agreed to pay to the testator interest upon the amount during his life, the principal to be disposed of by the defendant as the testator should thereafter direct. Certainly under this agreement, whether it could be called a trust or contract, or obligation, the money was given to the defendant' to dispose of in accordance with the understanding between the parties. There was no óbligation of the defendant to repay the money to the testator at any time. The title to the money vested in the defendant, and whether the defendant’s relation to the fund was strictly as trustee or not, the testator could not have compelled the defendant to repay him the money. (Gilman v. McArdle, 99 N. Y. 451.) Eor have the plaintiffs, as the' testator’s personal representatives, the right to compel the defendant to account to them for the money after the testator’s death.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit