Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York November 16, 1906 (Ghiglione v. Friedman)

Also known as

United States · · · 16-11-1906

Miller, J.:

The respondent seeks to sustain the dismissal of the complaint in the Municipal Court on two grounds, to wit: First, that the court did not have jurisdiction of the subject-matter; second, that the complaint did not state facts sufficient to constitute a cause of action. Construing the complaint with the liberality which should be accorded pleadings in the Municipal Court, it will be found to allege in effect that the defendant wrongfully, unlawfully and knowingly caused a notice of mechanic’s lien against plaintiff’s property to be filed in the clerk’s office of Mew York county upon a fictitious claim, 'thereby delaying the work on a building in process of construction, resulting in the loss of a month’s rental of the property.

The appellant urges that the action is one to recover damages for “an injury to property,” and that jurisdiction of such an action is conferred upon the Municipal Court by subdivision 14 of section 1 of.the Municipal Court Act (Laws of 1902, chap. 580). At-first blush it might appear that the term “injury to property” included only some physical injury to tangible property, but it is defined by subdivision 10 of section 3343 of the Code of Civil Procedure to be “ an actionable act, whereby the estate of another is lessened, other than a personal injury or the breach of a contract.” It is plain from this definition that the expression “injury to property,” as used in the act, is to be given a broad and unrestricted méaning, so as to include every invasion of one’s property rights by actionable wrong, and the decisions in this State have quite uniformly construed the expression in this manner. (Buckley v. Mayor, 30 App. Div. 463, 466; Stewart v. Lyman, 62 id. 182,185 ; Bogart v. Dart, 25 Hun, 395; Weiller v. Schreiber, 63 How. Pr. 491; Cleveland v. Barrows, 59 Barb. 364.)

The only question left for consideration, then, is whether the complaint states a cause of action, i. e.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.