Supreme Court of Arkansas December 17, 1906 (Montgomery v. Dane)
Also known as
United States · · · 17-12-1906
Hire, C. J.
Montgomery sued Mrs. Dane for a tract of land. She airswered, claiming ownership by a purchase from one Hamil, to whom she and her husband had conveyed, and asserting and claiming a homestead right in the property, and alleging that it was her husband’s homestead at time of its sale under execution under which Montgomery purchased; thar the sale was for a debt, not a lien on a homestead, and that Montgomery had acquired no title from his sale, and the same was a cloud on her title, and alleged a redemption from the sale to Hamil, and she asked a cancellation of Montgomery’s title and the quieting of her title. The cause was, after this answer and cross-complaint, transferred to equity, and prayer of cross-complaint granted, and Montgomery appealed.
The transaction with Hamil proved to be no more than a redemption of the property from a mortgage executed by herself and husband.
The case turns on whether or not the land was a homestead at the time of sale. If it was not, Montgomery’s title would prevail, possibly subject to subrogation of Mrs. Dane to the Hamil mortgage; and if the property was a homestead, the deed of Montgomery, based on an execution sale under a judgment obtained on a note given for a fine and costs, should be canceled. The facts were that Dane and wife lived upon the land for many years as a home, and he had no other property, and in 1896 they separated. Both left the place, but not the county >at that time. There were no children in the family, and Mrs. Dane went lo a married daughter’s house when they separated. One Douglass lived on the land in 1897. Whether he paid rent to Dane is not clear, but Dane went back to the land in 1898, and lived there till he mortgaged it to Hamil, and he then left the State. Mrs.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit