Supreme Court of Colorado January 15, 1906, No. 4731 (Nusly v. Curtis)

Also known as

United States · · · 15-01-1906

Mr. Justice Campbell

delivered the opinion of the court:

In this proceeding the plaintiffs in error asked for an interpretation of the second clause of the last will of Eliza O. Gallup, deceased, under which they claim as legatees. It reads:

“Second. Any and all sums of money which may at any time hereafter become due and payable to me or my estate, by or under any insurance policy upon the life of my husband Francis Gallup-, which may heretofore have been insured, payable to me or in my favor, I will and bequeath to the five sisters of my said husband, or to such of them as may be living at the time any such insurance moneys shall be actually collected and received by my executors, to be divided equally among said sisters or the survivors of them, as hereinbefore provided. ” *

The facts pertinent to the only question argued on this review" are that before the execution of the will an insurance policy for $5,000 upon the life of Francis Gallup was issued. About a year after its execution he died, and the amount of the policy on his life ($5,000) was received by the testatrix herself in her lifetime, which she commingled with her other funds, and afterwards reinvested. Not only was this amount not actually collected or received by the executors, but it was not traceable or identified in their hands. At the time of the death of the testatrix, which was more than eleven years after the will was executed, the plaintiffs in error, the five sisters of Francis Gallup who were mentioned in the will, were all living.

The only question raised and decided below, and the only one presented here, is as to the nature of this legacy. The plaintiffs in error say that it is a demonstrative legacy, and therefore it was not adeemed by the testatrix in her lifetime. The defendants in *467error say that it was a specific legacy, and was subject to be and as a matter of fact was, adeemed by the testatrix in her lifetime by collecting and commingling it with her other funds.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.