Court of Appeals of Kentucky December 11, 1906 (Austin v. Commonwealth)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-12-1906

*57Opinion op the Court by

Judge O’Rear

Affirming;.

The judgment of conviction of appellant was reversed on a former appeal because the trial court failed to properly instruct the jury as to the law of self-defense. 91 S. W. 267, 28 Ky. Law Rep. 1087. On a retrial of the ease the instruction indicated in the opinion as proper was given. The appellant was again convicted. On this appeal it is insisted that the effect of the self-defense instruction was nullified by a failure to properly state in the manslaughter instruction (under which defendant was found guilty) that one’s right to act in his self-defense was not properly set out in that instruction, also, in that it did not allude to the right of the accused to act on appearances. The court, in that instruction, told the jury that to strike and kill with a deadly weapon, in sudden affray, or sudden heat and passion, without malice, “and not in his necessary self-defense,” was voluntary manslaughter. It is insisted that the whole law of self-defense should have been stated there. But we think the instruction was sufficient in defining voluntary , manslaughter. That is what the court was there defining. As to what would constitutte “in his necessáry self-defense” was correctly set out in the instruction defining the defense. Instructions are intended to be read all together. Each one qualifies or limits all the others. They are intended to be, and are necessarily, so understood in their application. And when each instruction is correct within itself, and . and all are. consistent as a whole, and give all the law applicable to the case, the practice cannot be deemed prejudicial to the defendant because the same ideas might have been better expressed.

In the closing arguments to the jury, attorneys *58representing the .commonwealth are charged with having abused their privilege, and indulged in unwarranted statements to the jury.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.