Wisconsin Supreme Court January 9, 1906 (Davis v. Schmidt)
Also known as
United States · · · 09-01-1906
Keewin, J.
1. Error is assigned in denying plaintiff’s motion that a verdict be directed in his favor. It is contended *463by appellant that, because the answer admits that judgment was recovered for one year’s interest against defendants, the ■determination of the court in such action for the recovery of interest is conclusive between the parties and their privies, and that the defendants cannot now question the plaintiff’s right to recover on the note in suit. The answer denies generally the plaintiff’s right to recover, and the admission in the answer that judgment was recovered for one year’s interest upon the note in suit is not sufficient to conclude the defendants in a suit on a different cause of action, where it is not alleged that the same matters were litigated or determined in the suit for interest. There is nothing in the allegation of the complaint, nor the admission in the answer respecting the recovery of judgment, which shows that the judgment was recovered upon the merits, or that the defense interposed in such action for the recovery of interest was the-same as the defense in this action. The mere allegation of the recovery of interest in tire complaint and the admission thereof in the answer is not sufficient to conclude the defendants in this action. It does not appear from the pleadings that the defense set up here was litigated or determined in the former action. Hence the judgment in the former action upon a different cause of action is not binding here., Wentworth v. Racine Co. 99 Wis. 26, 74 N. W. 551; Cromwell v. County of Sac, 94 U. S. 351; 1 Van Fleet, Former Adj. § 30.
It is further claimed that defendants, with full knowledge of the facts and having more than one remedy, elected their remedy by commencing suit against L. M. Goldberg Company, which remedy is inconsistent with-the defense now set up, and therefore they cannot maintain their present defense to this action.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit