Court of Appeals for the First Circuit February 21, 1906, No. 608 (Winsor v. Ayer)
Also known as
United States · · · 21-02-1906
PUTNAM, Circuit Judge.
This is a case of collision off the coast of New Hampshire or Massachusetts, between the deeply-laden lumber schooner John T. Williams and the fishing schooner Metamora running light, in which the Williams was sunk. The District Court held that the Metamora was alone in fault, and decreed the entire damages against her. The collision, as found by the learned district judge, occurred about quarter past 6 o’clock on a December evening, when the night was clear, the moon three days old, setting at quarter past 7, with the wind strong to the northwest, and on the open ocean. IJnder the circumstances, it should not have happened, so much so that we necessarily conclude there was fault somewhere. The Metamora seeks to discredit the case of the Williams because the libel alleges that she was on a course somewhat different from that found by the District Court. Admiralty is not sufficiently technical to attach importance, except under some peremptory circumstances, to such discrepancies in collision cases, where the facts are often not correctly ascertained by the parties themselves until developed by the taking of proofs. It is sufficient here that the material circumstances .of the case do not depend on this discrepancy.
The Williams was sailing close-hauled on the starboard tack, so that the somewhat heavy sea caught her under the. starboard bow, and increased her tendency to yaw and drift to port which the admiralty courts have frequently recognized. The Metamora was sailing free on the port tack, and had little tendency, therefore, to drift or yaw. When the vessels first sighted each other they were port to port, red to red. The crew of the Williams on deck were engaged in pumping, and the only proper deck watch was the master, who was at the wheel. The mate had been directed by the master to go forward occasionally and look for lights.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit