Court of Appeals for the Second Circuit April 2, 1906 (Higgins v. Hamburg-American Packet Co.)

Also known as

United States · · · 02-04-1906

PER CURIAM.

In the view we have taken of the case the defenses based on the claims of exemption from liability by reason of the Harter act and of certain provisions in the bill of lading need not he discussed. The cargo was shipped at Baltimore on respondent’s steamship Bulgaria to be forwarded to Hamburg. When the steamship reached a point in the River Elbe opposite Brunshausen, and some 14 miles below Hamburg, the water in the river was low, and under a provision of the bill of lading, and in accordance with the usual procedure in such conditions, the Bulgaria, on the afternoon of May 27, 1902, anchored at the customary place, and some 300 or 400 yards from a point where the steamship Patricia, also belonging to the respondent, was anchored, and proceeded to discharge a portion of her cargo into lighters belonging to the respondent. One of the lighters was made fast on the port side of the Bulgaria near her stem, and the portion of the cargo for which damage is claimed herein had been discharged into this lighter. During the 27th and *2728th, with lighters alongside, the steamers had swung clear of each other with the turning of the various tides. At about 4 o’clock on the morning of May 29th, just as the tide was commencing to flood, the Bulgaria began to swing and drift broadside up the river toward the Patricia, and, while so swinging, it is claimed that she stuck in the mud forward. In any event, her stern continued to swing, and her officers saw that she was likely to collide with the Patricia, and started her engines ahead, and ordered the lighter cast off, in order to prevent it from being crushed between the two steamships. The lighter went adrift, caught on a safety hook of the rudder of the Patricia, sprung a leak, broke the hook, and sank before it could be towed ashore.

The evidence indicates that one of the steamships had dragged her anchor during the preceding night.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.