U.S. Circuit Court for the District of Eastern Wisconsin May 12, 1906 (General Electric Co. v. National Electric Co.)
Also known as
United States · · · 12-05-1906
SEAMAN, Circuit Judge
(after stating the facts)'. The oral argument at the hearing impressed me strongly in favor of the validity and great utility of the patent in suit, irrespective of the important consideration that Judge Thompson had reached like conclusion in an adjudication in the Southern District of Ohio against the Bullock Electric Manufacturing Company. 146 Fed.-. Since the argument I have read the briefs and the opinion of Judge Thompson, have examined as well the material testimony, and am convinced that the Reist device was a marked advance in the art, disclosing the structure for an armature core which was justly entitled to letters patent. The discussions by counsel and experts on one side and the other are interesting, both historically and in the subject-matter, but neithér the issues involved nor the time at my disposal warrant extension of this opinion to review the various contentions. I deem it sufficient, therefore, to state the deductions of fact upon which the decree for the complainant is authorized, under my understanding of the evidence.
When Reist entered the field with his device for an armature core in 1893, not only was the great desirability of ventilation for such cores well recognized, but inventors had made numerous attempts to that end without success. In each prior device the ventilation was obtained with such deduction from the capacity of the machine that the device was worthless for practical use, and the proof is undisputed that for several years the trade had rejected and abandoned all such devices, so that unventilated armature cores, with their known tendency to overheating, were universally used. Nevertheless, the solution by Reist in the patent means cannot rest patentability on the fact alone of its success where others had failed in the quest for ventilation, although that fact may be helpful as one of the tests of invention.
Read the full text
This document is published by courtlistener.com.
Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.
Sign in to Moonlit