Supreme Court of New Hampshire June 29, 1907 (Hub Construction Co. v. New England Breeders' Club)

Also known as

United States · · · 29-06-1907

Parsons, C. J.

Mandamus

is the appropriate remedy by which to enforce the right of corporate stockholders and members to an inspection of the books and records of the corporation, and of creditors of the corporation in cases where such right is given by statute. 10 Cyc. 961, s. 20b; High Ex. Rem.,

ss.

308, 312; 2 Spell. Ex. Rel.,

s.

1610;

Queen

v.

Railway,

3 E. & B. 784. The proceeding is therefore to be considered as an application for such writ, and not as a bill of discovery. This is especially clear in this state, since the original of the statute under consideration was adopted in 1830 (Laws 1830,

c.

13, s. 1), when, whatever may be the fact as to the existence of equitable principles as a part of the common law of the state, there was no court with general chancery

*285

powers, and the accepted construction of the law was that the court had no chancery power except what was specifically conferred by statute.

Reynolds

v.

Fibre Co.,

71 N. H. 332, 333;

Wells

v.

Pierce,

27 N. H. 503, 512:

Dover

v.

Portsmouth Bridge,

17 N. H. 200, 212. It is not probable, as the law was then understood, that in 1830 the legislature, in granting a right of inspection of the votes and proceedings of corporations to creditors whose demands were unpaid, contemplated a proceeding in equity for discovery, general authority for which was not specifically conferred upon the court until twelve years later.

Reynolds

v.

Fibre Co., supra;

Laws 1828, Nov. Sess.,

c.

95,

s.

9 (Act of January 2, 1829); Laws 1832,

c.

89, s. 9; R. S., c. 171,

s.

6. As the proceeding is not a bill for discovery, or a petition in the nature of such a bill, it is immaterial whether the allegations of the petition are sufficient to sustain such a proceeding. The authorities cited by the defendant to sustain his contentions in this respect, and' those construing statutes authorizing proceedings of this nature, are not in point.

This conclusion, however, does not meet all the objections-raised by the defendant.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.