Supreme Court of North Carolina October 10, 1907 (Mangum v. North Carolina Railroad)

Also known as

United States · · · 10-10-1907

BeowN,

J.

Tbe evidence tends to prove that tbe plaintiff, on tbe night of 4 July, 1908, was a passenger on defendant’s

*153

train,

en route

from Ealeigb to Danville, Va. He passed through the gates of the defendant’s station at Ealeigh, and as he was waiting along the platform used by passengers to reach the cars he was run into- and seriously injured by a truck loaded with newspapers. It was in evidence that the man in charge of the truck was not employed by the railroad, but was employed by a newspaper, and it was his business to handle the newspaper mail. When the newspaper mail reaches the station in time it is the custom for the railroad truck hands to take the mail from the gate down to the train. When the newspapers arrive too late to be taken at the gate by the truck hands the man who brings the newspapers down from the office takes them down to the cars and delivers them to the mail agents at the mail car. Witness E. E. Lumsden testified that the newspaper mail was handled by the railroad porters when it got to. the gate befbre the transfer clerk and the porters went down with the regular mail. If it arrived in time the railroad porters took the mail down to the mail car, but if the newspaper mail got to the gate after the porters had gone down with the mail, the person who brought the newspaper mail took it down to the mail car and unloaded it. “When we went down with the mail on the night of 4 July, 1903, the newspaper mail had not come. A colored boy, named Lunsford Davis, handled the newspaper mail to the depot for the newspaper at that time.” The witness heard of the accident either that night or .the next day.

The only question presented for our consideration is the liability of defendant to plaintiff' for the negligence of the newspaper porter, upon the above facts.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.