Supreme Court of South Carolina September 17, 1907, 6659 (Windham v. Howell)

Also known as

United States · · · 17-09-1907

lead-opinion

September 17, 1907. The opinion of the Court was delivered by This action was commenced for the partition of certain lands in Darlington County. The defendants, George C. Howell and Louisiana Howell, answered, denying the allegations of the complaint and setting up title to the land described. The first trial of this issue of title was before Judge Townsend and a jury and resulted in a verdict for the defendants, under the direction of the Court. On appeal this Court reversed said judgment and remanded the case "for trial of the issue of title as made by the pleadings." 68 S.C. 478, 47 S.E., 715. Thereafter the case came on for trial before Judge Gage and a jury. After considerable testimony was introduced for plaintiffs and defendants, Judge Gage, stating what he conceived to be the issue in the case, submitted in his charge the following special issue to the jury: "Were the names of John W. Windham, C.M. Windham, Mary L. Wadford and Eliza Troublefield in the deed *Page 190 in issue there written before James Windham signed and delivered the deed, or after he signed and delivered the deed?" Upon this issue the jury found that the names were written in the deed "before" its execution, judgment was entered accordingly, and order granted by Judge Gage referring all the equitable issues to the master, from which this appeal is taken. In his order, Judge Gage, among other things, said: "Both parties claimed under the deed of James Windham to Eliza Windham and others. That deed created only a life estate, and it has been so held by the Supreme Court on appeal in this case in a former judgment herein. That being so, and the uncontradicted testimony showing that some of the plaintiffs and defendant Louisiana Howell have interests in the property that is subject to partition, the plaintiffs are entitled to proceed on the equity side of this Court for such further proceedings as may be necessary and proper to effectuate the partition.

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.