Appellate Division of the Supreme Court of the State of New York January 11, 1907 (Blewett v. Hoyt)

Also known as

United States · · · 11-01-1907

Ingraham, J.:

The question presented on this appeal is whether the case on appeal should contain the grounds upon which .counsel for the defendant Hoyt moved to dismiss the complaint. It seems that after the plaintiff rested, counsel for the defendant Hoyt made a motion to dismiss the complaint, stating at large -Seven grounds upon which- that motion was based. From the stenographer’s minutes it appears that he commenced his argument and continued until recess, when the argument was suspended; that after recess counsel for the defendant Hoyt said: “I desire to state that the defendants rest upon the plaintiffs’’case.” The plaintiffs then made a motion, to strike out portions of the testimony, and then made a motion to; direct a verdict for the plaintiffs.' The court then said : “ How the question is on- the motion of the plaintiffs and the defendant Hunt and for the direction of a verdict against the *33defendant Hoyt. Tour motion, Mr. Guthrie, is still to dismiss the-complaint,” to'which Mr. Guthrie replied.: “My motion is first to dismiss the complaint, in the alternative, a ruling that the plaintiffs in no event are entitled to recover more than nominal damages.” The court then, after stating the several motions, said : “ I will hear Mr. Guthrie, I think, since he had the floor and has started. Does not this take the question away from the jury, gentlemen ? I think it does, and we have quite an- important question here.” After further discussion the court held that these several motions made a question of law for the court, when the jury seems to have been discharged without objection, and counsel for the defendant continued this motion to dismiss the complaint.

It appears that a long discussion followed, counsel for all of the parties being heard. The court subsequently denied the defendant’s motions to dismiss the complaint or to direct a verdict for nominal damages, and granted the motion of the plaintiffs for .

Read the full text

This document is published by courtlistener.com.

Moonlit adds the citation network, article-level links and cross-references, which are available to search for free.